Respond Only to an Offered Counterproposal
Person whose offer was declined to the other owner · no probing after no
You offered two paperbacks for another adult's puzzle, using small items each of you owns. They say, "No to two books. I would swap the puzzle for just that one paperback instead." Their concrete new proposal is voluntary and audible; you have not accepted it. You can check that proposal if you want to consider it, or decline it. If their reply had only been "No," silence, a reject button, or a polite goodbye, there would be no counteroffer to explore.
Before you use this
Use this when
Only a specific counterproposal they actually volunteered permits considering that proposal. It does not reveal a hidden bottom line, invite questions about reasons for refusal, or require you to keep negotiating.
Stop if
A refusal to continue ends the exchange. No repeated bids, questions to discover what would change their mind, or pressure justified by a possible eventual deal. Essential resources, existing obligations, and formal disputes are outside this optional small-item example.
Your first line
Recommended first line
Choose this only because a concrete new proposal was volunteered and you want to consider it. Repeating it is not acceptance. If there is no such proposal, say "Okay" and end your offer without this question.
If they withdraw the proposal, decline further discussion, or do not answer, stop rather than ask for a hidden limit.
You would give me the puzzle for my one paperback. Is that right?
Choose the step that fits your situation
Choose your goal
Line for this goal
Choose this only because a concrete new proposal was volunteered and you want to consider it. Repeating it is not acceptance. If there is no such proposal, say "Okay" and end your offer without this question.
If they withdraw the proposal, decline further discussion, or do not answer, stop rather than ask for a hidden limit.
You would give me the puzzle for my one paperback. Is that right?
These are examples, not every possible response. If none fits, nothing has happened yet, or you're unsure, leave the response unselected or use Clear response. This does not confirm that the scenario applies; follow the scope and stop conditions above.
Clears this scenario's response. Your goal stays the same.
What you can observe
What happened next?
For: Check the proposal before deciding