Do Not Join In Putting Down Someone Who Is Absent

You to a friend criticizing someone who is not there

After a casual game, your friend says, "I'm frustrated with Sam. He's useless, and he never turns up." Sam is absent. You saw Sam attend the last game, but do not know the rest of the story or Sam's feelings. You do not want to join the insult; you are willing to listen briefly to your friend's own experience without endorsing a judgment about Sam.

Before you use this

Use this when

Ordinary social criticism, not a disclosure of harm or a request for protection. You can decline the label even if some underlying complaint is true.

Stop if

Do not use this to silence someone seeking help about harm, witnessing wrongdoing, or making a formal complaint. Work rights, required reporting, threats, and ongoing coercion are outside this conversation.

Your first line

Acknowledge a feeling only if your friend actually states it. You may correct one ordinary fact you personally know, without judging anyone's character or passing the story on.

Do not push a confrontation, tell them to find a manager, or keep offering advice they have not requested. If the labeling or pressure continues, stop your participation.

I don't want to call Sam names.

These are examples, not every possible response. If none fits, nothing has happened yet, or you're unsure, leave the response unselected or use Clear response. This does not confirm that the scenario applies; follow the scope and stop conditions above.

Clears this scenario's response. Your goal stays the same.

What you can observe

What happened next?

For: Decline the personal label

If the situation has changed

Does a stop condition now apply?

If a listed stop condition applies in your situation, stop using this script.

Back to all scenarios