Decline to Judge a Friend's Dispute

You to an adult friend · being asked to take a side after hearing one account

A friend says another friend criticized their choice of a film for a casual movie night, then asks you to say who was wrong. You have heard only this friend's account and did not witness the exchange. There is no report of harm, threat, or dispute over housing or money. You can decline the judge role whether you choose to keep listening or end this conversation. Neither choice makes you a messenger or mediator.

Before you use this

Use this when

A one-sided request to judge an ordinary disagreement about a voluntary social activity. You have not verified the events or heard the other person's account. No one has authorized a joint discussion, and you are not taking responsibility for resolving the dispute.

Stop if

Do not apply a neutrality rule to a disclosure of harm, danger, or events you actually witnessed. Stop this ordinary-dispute script if safety, housing, money, legal issues, or a real responsibility to give an account is involved.

Your first line

Choose this only if you actually want to keep listening now. Listening to your friend's account does not certify it, mean both people are equally responsible, or authorize you to contact the other person.

If the account becomes a report of harm or danger, leave the casual-dispute framing. If your friend keeps pressing you to judge after your clarification, you can stop listening rather than bargain over your role.

I've only heard your account, so I won't decide who's right or pass messages. I can listen, though.

Choose the step that fits your situation

Choose your goal

Line for this goal

Choose this only if you actually want to keep listening now. Listening to your friend's account does not certify it, mean both people are equally responsible, or authorize you to contact the other person.

If the account becomes a report of harm or danger, leave the casual-dispute framing. If your friend keeps pressing you to judge after your clarification, you can stop listening rather than bargain over your role.

I've only heard your account, so I won't decide who's right or pass messages. I can listen, though.

These are examples, not every possible response. If none fits, nothing has happened yet, or you're unsure, leave the response unselected or use Clear response. This does not confirm that the scenario applies; follow the scope and stop conditions above.

Clears this scenario's response. Your goal stays the same.

What you can observe

What happened next?

For: Keep listening without judging

If the situation has changed

Does a stop condition now apply?

If a listed stop condition applies in your situation, stop using this script.

Back to all scenarios