Clarify What Creative Feedback Is Wanted
You to a friend who requested feedback · agreeing one limited question first
A friend has made an original sketch for their own enjoyment and has explicitly asked you for feedback. They made it available for you to view; it contains no private material or other people's work that would require additional permission. This is not a job review, paid critique, or submission decision. You feel able to describe where your attention goes in the picture, but not to judge technical drawing skill. You do not yet know what feedback the friend wants, and you have not agreed to review or revise it.
Before you use this
Use this when
A direct request about an ordinary, shareable personal work. Viewing permission does not include forwarding, public posting, asking another reviewer, or making changes.
Stop if
Stop if permission to view is uncertain or withdrawn, or the request becomes professional evaluation, confidential material, or a dispute about ownership or rights. Do not broaden feedback when the requested scope is unclear.
Your first line
Recommended first line
Ask about the actual work and request, not whether the friend can "take criticism" or secretly wants praise. Clarifying a request does not require you to accept it. You can offer a limited observation, decline, or leave feedback unstarted.
Do not assume consent to critique every aspect, edit the work, share it, or continue after the friend withdraws.
What part of the sketch would you like feedback on?
These are examples, not every possible response. If none fits, nothing has happened yet, or you're unsure, leave the response unselected or use Clear response. This does not confirm that the scenario applies; follow the scope and stop conditions above.
Clears this scenario's response. Your goal stays the same.
What you can observe
What happened next?
For: Ask the requested scope before judging