Ask What a Vague Criticism Refers To

You → a friend commenting on a shared hobby activity

After you and a friend show your public, non-sensitive photo collage at a casual hobby gathering, your friend says, "You were dismissive when we presented it." They have not named a particular action. You do not yet know what they mean or whether their account is accurate. You can ask about one behavior without agreeing to a personality label, or choose not to discuss the feedback.

Before you use this

Use this when

An optional conversation between adult peers about one ordinary behavior during a hobby presentation, with no assessment, employment or other power consequence. A correction of a date or a preference for a different collage style is a different question.

Stop if

Stop this approach for insults, family comparisons used to demean you, repeated humiliation, pressure to doubt your own memory, threats or formal performance consequences. A sharper tone is not evidence of care.

Your first line

Ask what happened, not why they think you are a certain kind of person. An example is information to check, not proof. A style preference can remain a preference. You need not apologize to keep the conversation going, and you can stop even if an example is offered.

What did I say or do during the presentation that felt dismissive?

These are examples, not every possible response. If none fits, nothing has happened yet, or you're unsure, leave the response unselected or use Clear response. This does not confirm that the scenario applies; follow the scope and stop conditions above.

Clears this scenario's response. Your goal stays the same.

What you can observe

What happened next?

For: Ask for one specific behavior

If the situation has changed

Does a stop condition now apply?

If a listed stop condition applies in your situation, stop using this script.

Back to all scenarios